The Alcoran of Mahmet by Alexander Ross (1649)
|Title: The Alcoran of Mahomet||Translator: Alexander Ross||Dated: 1649|
|Publisher: None stated. London||English/Arabic: English only||Cover: Calf leather|
Preface length: 51 (Includes material both before and after the Qur'an
|Pages (Qur'an only): 394||Number of Volumes: 1|
|Footnotes: None. Contains margin notes||General Notes:|
Labeling the Alexander Ross
as a translation adds to the confusion.
A translation may imply a direct
conversion of the words from Arabic to English.
Alexander “Ross did not know Arabic and
relied completely on the French translation by
Andrew du Ryer who served as the French Consul
The 1649 Alexander Ross translation began amidst a state of civil war steeped in religious controversy. The controversy between the Catholic translator and the new Puritan leadership would be cited and inserted into the preface of this new Qur’an. The other aspect of the controversy remains today as this translation is consistently cited in a pejorative sense in Muslim translations of the Qur’an or Muslim books about the Qur’an. For example, the book titled The Qur’ân and the Orientalists published in 2004 states that Alexander Ross “…aimed at exposing what he called the ‘Turkish Vanities.’ This phrase betrays, on the one hand his and his contemporary Europeans’ dislike of the Turks…” (MoharAli 326).
In the early 1600’s the English were
keenly interested in the
and its contents because they were increasingly
coming into contact with Muslims through trade
or confronted on the open sea by marauding
By 1640 the English interest resulted in
the hiring of the first Professor of Arabic at
Alexander Ross began his translation
under the English King Charles I and completed
it under the reign of Oliver Cromwell the Lord
In March 1649 an English Commonwealth Colonel petitioned and informed the Commonwealth government that Qur’ans were being printed on English soil (Matar 83). The Commonwealth government immediately acted by seizing the printed Qur’ans and jailing the printer (Matar 83). The State Council also immediately issued a warrant for Alexander Ross and demanded his appearance before their council. On March 31, 1649 Alexander Ross appeared before the council to answer the charges (Matar 83). There are no surviving transcripts of this meeting, but the encounter favored Alexander Ross who was allowed to print the Qur’an (Matar 83). It finally became available and for sale to the general public on May 7, 1649 (Matar 83).
of Alexander Ross ultimately served two
first and original purpose was to expose the
false teachings of Islam.
He believed that Islam was not only a
physical threat, but a spiritual deception that
finally merited attention.
A second and originally unplanned purpose
was spawned by the arrest warrant from the
Ross would use the
by inserting some new prefatory material
directly attacking the new
The aim of this translation is clearly explained in the various letters and attachments inserted before and after the translation. Alexander Ross retained and translated the prefatory material contained in the original 1647 French Qur’an, but added some of his own material. Some of the additional material was inserted after the initial printing and disrupts the pagination. The added sections include: The Translator to the Christian Reader; The Translation to the Reader and a needful caveat or admonition for them who desire to know what use may be of, or if there be danger in reading the Alcoran. The first added section is the Translation to the Reader. In this brief three page section Alexander Ross details the importance of this translation. He begins by acknowledging the abundance of diverse heretical sects and believes it “…good to bring it to their Colours, that so viewing thine enemies in their full body…” (Ross A2). Ross displays a credible grasp of fundamental Islamic beliefs as he discusses topics such as jihad and the reliability of hadith passages (Ross A2). The last page of this section contains a hint eluding to the censorship problems he faced with the new Puritan government when he mentions that some “…were unwilling this should see the press” (Ross A3). He concludes this section by stating the Qur’an is a poison that has infected many minds and the publication of this book, with all its false teachings, will prove the Christian faith is true and ultimately strengthen all Christians who dare read The Alcoran of Mahomet (Ross A3). Publishing an overtly non-Christian book in a Christian land was a risky venture for Ross, but one he felt worth the effort to undertake in the hopes that the religion of Islam would be undermined by its own words.
Alexander Ross was absolutely convinced that any Christian thoroughly familiar with their scriptures would readily see the errors contained in the Qur’an (Ross EE). Ross recorded this statement in additional material not originally considered for the Qur’an. This is part of the material that was inserted later as a result of the warrant to appear before the council. It is not stated, but is likely that one of the chief concerns of the Puritans were that innocent Christians would be converted to Islam by reading the Qur’an translated by Ross. Ross firmly believed that his duty to the Christian world was to publish and expose the Qur’an. His reasoning was that by translating the Qur’an and revealing all its falsehood that Christians would be encouraged in their faith as they readily observed its plethora of false doctrine. Finally, the Qur’an itself would prove to the Christian world that it is a false religion and the publication of his English Qur’an would severely damage the cause of Islam and the Turks in particular.
of Alexander Ross was a popular book in
Matar, Nabil. “Alexander Ross and the First English Translation of the Qur’an.” Muslim World. 88.1 (1998): 81-92.
Ross, Alexander, trans.
Alcoran of Mahomet.
By Sier Du Ryer.
|Verse Rendering for Comparison:
2:106: "He will not alter his commandments, neither forgets them; he will moreover teach other more profitable, or of the like nature"
3:54: "The Jews conspired against Jesus, and God caused their conspirace to turn against them, he knoweth the designs of conspiriators"
4:34: "The men shall have authority over the women; they shall have them in the keeping; they shall have in their power the wealth that God shall give them; and have care of what shall be convenient to be expended for them. Discreet and obedient wives in the absence of their husbands, the Commandments of God, make remonstrances to them that shall be disobedient, and remove them from your Bed, chastise them. If they obey you, seek not occasion to abuse them unjustly.
5:51: 'Oh ye that believe! obey not the Jews, nor the Christians, they mutually obey each other in their impietie, he that shall obey them, shall be like unto them, God guideth not the unjust"
5:101: 'oh ye that are wise! I have the fear of God before your eyes, peradventure you shall be happy. Oh! ye believers desire not the knowledge of all things, you will afflict yourselves; be not curious to know at what time the Alcoran was went from Heaven, God pardoneth your former curiosity, your Predecessours were alike curious, and in the number of unbelievers.
9:29: "Fight against them that believe not in God, no the day of Judgment, that forbid not to act what God hath prohibited, and his Prophet hath forbidden, and that judge not according to the Law of truth, wherein they were instructed, who heretofore received the written law: they chuse rather to pay Tribute, then to be converted, therefore they are contemptible."
10:94: If thou doubtrest what we have taught thee, repair to them that have read the Scriptures before thee; what the Lord hath taught thee is most true; be not thou of them that doubt